AvidCX logo

Stanley Martin Homes

Verified homebuyer feedback, ratings, and recent survey insights.

Overall Star Rating

★★★★★

4.4 / 5 from 11,612 surveys

Rating distribution

Based on 11612 surveys

5 Stars
60%
4 Stars
25%
3 Stars
9%
2 Stars
3%
1 Stars
2%

Quality of Home

★★★★★

4.3 / 5

Quality of Experience

★★★★★

4.3 / 5

Caring Displayed

★★★★★

4.4 / 5

Overall Responsiveness

★★★★★

4.4 / 5

Recent survey feedback

Show Latest →

November 2026Silver Lake Pointe SFD

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

This was a large move for us. SM was very accommodating, considering we were not sure which home to buy and did not have much time to spend looking. It would have been less stressful if the closing location was closer to the development. Most items of concern have been addressed since closing. Our lawn was in pretty rough shape compared to our neighbors. With a little work it will come around. We are very pleased with the model we chose (Seaton II) It is a perfect retirement home for us. I also like the development location and the flooring and countertops compared to other locations.

November 2026Presidents Pointe Towns

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

The quality of the home looks sturdy and the services was great

November 2026Providence at Trolley Run Station

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

Sales agent Hailey very helpful. , professional and attentive to our needs

November 2026Colonial Circle SFD

Overall Star Rating: 4.0 / 5

From start to finish, we experienced a very warm and professional interaction. The project manager, Ali and the realtor, Mike, were our favorites.

November 2026Brack Ranch SFD

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

I felt well taken care of the entire time and truly listened to. The process was quick and simple. The salesperson, Valerie, answered all my questions and consistently demonstrated great professionalism throughout the process.

November 2026The Retreat at Laurelbrook

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

Tanner was awesome throughout the building and hand-off process.

November 2026Avalon Park Tavares

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

When we began our search for a house in Florida, the one thing we believed we could eliminate was new construction. We had the same opinions that we had developed decades ago: 1) we could never afford a new house at today’s costs and rates. 2) we could never find new neighborhoods that were not sterile or devoid of personality or so far out as to feel isolated. 3) and the thing that closed down all showings before we even got to number 1 or 2: excessive VOC ratings, especially formaldehyde. Everything had what other people considered “new house smell” but for me was a personal assault on my senses, resulting in headache, runny nose and constant coughing. We had viewed the Webber by Stanley Martin a year before we bought and unfortunately, as much as I loved the layout—there was still the smell. Then when we came back this year, after looking at over a dozen pre-loved houses, our daughter insisted we just go look at the design we liked in the Avalon Park Tavares division because it was closer than the one we viewed before AND there had been some changes, most notably to the flooring. We stopped on a Friday evening about an hour before closing and unknown to us at the time, just before Cipriano was due to leave for a week’s vacation. Not only did the house welcome us immediately with NO SMELL, Cipriano was welcoming and refreshingly personable without the sale-sy vibe. By the time we left, we had more questions and interest than we had intended to pursue. Cip made himself available to us by phone and message the entire week he was on vacation. He patiently answered questions as well as put us direct contact with the people and systems that could continue to move us forward at the pace we were most comfortable. There was never any steering or pushback, only acknowledgement of what we identified as a next step to making a purchase happen. And it did happen. We specified move in ready only, single story only and the Avalon Park Tavares neighborhood only. He showed us what he had available and we constantly came back to the property on Senna Way. Once paperwork had been submitted and the process was underway, we asked to take pictures and measurements so we could order window coverings and appliances to be available the day after closing. And we met Tanner. Any question we had was answered immediately, he knew every measurement, specification and variant. His attention to detail was only overshadowed by his follow through, and his patience with questions he probably had to answer on a daily basis was appreciated. I will admit, when we were notified of a “required” new home owner orientation, it seemed like an unnecessary and inconvenient step before closing. We’ve owned six homes over 40 years, but... Clayton met us on the property and his casual and comfortable manner diffused my irritation immediately. His comprehensive presentation made it clear why the orientation was one of the most important processes we completed. I can only imagine the time and irritation we would have avoided in all six homes we had owned if we had been aware of even half of the information Clayton provided. As with everyone we dealt with during our purchase, he made himself available by text, phone and email for whatever came up. This was particularly important for me as I do not like my lack of understanding processes or expectations to label me a nuisance. There was so much information—all of which was important at different points of the first 30 days and none of which we could have assumed. As with Cipriano and Tanner, Clayton never made us feel like we were a bother, he was patient and respectful no matter how many times I asked the same simple questions. We are enjoying our first new home experience, in spite of the acclimation and endless paperwork. Each concern we had prior to purchase has turned out to be a non-issue. Every unsure circumstance has been met with professional grace and resolved. If the workmanship of this house stands up to Florida weather and terrain as well as our personal encounters with the people in the company, we just made the best purchase of seven. Thank you Cipriano, Tanner and Clayton. We smile every day because you made this journey so easy.

November 2026Trestle Ridge at Brunswick Forest

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

Streamlined process. Very thorough explanations during the process.

November 2026Twyla Walk 2o2

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

I don’t like the rock in the driveway

November 2026Quartz District 2o2

Overall Star Rating: 5.0 / 5

It was really good